Step 1: Instead of using an eyebrow pencil, I use a powder that matches with my hair color. Apply with an angled brush and then use a brow brush to soften the look.
Step 2: Keep the eyeliner thin and stick to softer colors like brown or gray. Try lining the inner rims of your eyes with a bombshell intensity eyeliner(http://www.covergirl.com/eye-makeup/eyeliner/felt-tip-eyeliner). To do this, lift up your eyelid gently and push the eyeliner into the rim of your lids.
Step 3: Apply this bombshell mascara (http://www.covergirl.com/eye-makeup/mascara/bombshell-volume-mascara) one to two coats and run a brow brush through your lashes to get rid of clumps.